Edition:

Last updated: December 1, 2019

Apply For Rankings | Improve Your Rankings | Evaluation Criteria

 
Best

Top 10 Payroll Services

Best Payroll Services - December 2019

Rank

Company Name

Year
Founded

Revenue

Fulltime
Employees

Active
Clients

Client
Retention
Rate

Pricing

Major Clients

Other Core
Services

Methods of Payment

Methods of Payment

Tax Compliance

Tax Compliance

Automation

Automation

Volume

Volume

Support

Support

Overall Score

0
100
 
G
VG
E
 

Change in Rank

BenefitMall BenefitMall
Talk to a Representative: 844-499-2600
Key Facts For BenefitMall
  • Major Clients:
    Confidential
  • Year Founded:
    1979
  • Fulltime Employees:
    1,400+
  • Active Clients:
    200,000+
  • Revenue:
    Above $10 million
  • Client Retention Rate:
    97
  • Pricing:
    L
  • Website:
    employers.benefitmall.com
Request A Quote
Positive 83.3% 5 Reviews
I have had great experiences with BenefitMall...
Brian B
Positive
I've always had a great experience with Benef...
Scott Byrne
Negative 16.7% 1 Reviews
If you are a business owner! Be aware of the...
Give Me Body Body Sculpting Beauty Bar

Methods of Payment

Tax Compliance

Automation

Volume

Support

Paycor Paycor
Talk to a Representative: 800-381-0053
Service Offerings:
Key Facts For Paycor
  • Major Clients:
    A-Tec Ambulance, Focal Point, Cincinnati Zoo
  • Year Founded:
    2011
  • Fulltime Employees:
    30
  • Active Clients:
    100+
  • Revenue:
    $1 million - $3 million
  • Client Retention Rate:
    95
  • Pricing:
    L
  • Website:
    www.paycor.com
Request A Quote
Positive 55.6% 5 Reviews
Paycor: Welcome Home
Kevin Cowman
Negative 33.3% 3 Reviews
Tried to contact my 'success team,' at Paycor...
Cynthia Miller-Witsken
Neutral 11.1% 1 Reviews
Easy to find easy to find
Brenda

Methods of Payment

Tax Compliance

Automation

Volume

Support

Square Square
Talk to a Representative: (855) 700-6000
Key Facts For Square
  • Major Clients:
    Confidential
  • Year Founded:
    2009
  • Fulltime Employees:
    1000+
  • Active Clients:
    1000+
  • Revenue:
    Above $10 million
  • Client Retention Rate:
    95
  • Pricing:
    L
  • Website:
    squareup.com
Request A Quote
Positive0% Write Review

 

Negative0% Write Review

 

Neutral0% Write Review

 

Methods of Payment

Tax Compliance

Automation

Volume

Support

Client Solutions Group Client Solutions Group
Talk to a Representative: 716-785-6006
Key Facts For Client Solutions Group
  • Major Clients:
    Available upon request.
  • Year Founded:
    2012
  • Fulltime Employees:
    100+
  • Active Clients:
    200+
  • Revenue:
    $5 million - $10 million
  • Client Retention Rate:
    97
  • Pricing:
    M
  • Website:
    www.client-solutions-group.com
Request A Quote
Positive0% Write Review

 

Negative0% Write Review

 

Neutral0% Write Review

 

Methods of Payment

Tax Compliance

Automation

Volume

Support

Axis Payroll Inc
Talk to a Representative: +1 845-418-4286
Service Offerings:
Key Facts For Axis Payroll Inc
  • Major Clients:
    Confidential
  • Year Founded:
    2013
  • Fulltime Employees:
    10+
  • Active Clients:
    20+
  • Revenue:
    $250,000 - $1 million
  • Client Retention Rate:
    86
  • Pricing:
    L
  • Website:
    www.axispayroll.com
Request A Quote
Positive0% Write Review

 

Negative0% Write Review

 

Neutral0% Write Review

 

Methods of Payment

Tax Compliance

Automation

Volume

Support

6
1971
$5 million - $10 million
158
600,000+
90
L
Rizzo & DiGiacco, Ralph Pontiac Honda, KB Advertising Specilaities, Canadaigua Emergancy Squad
97
95
97
94
96
95.8%
NC
Paychex, Inc. Paychex, Inc.
Talk to a Representative: 585-385-6666
Key Facts For Paychex, Inc.
  • Major Clients:
    Rizzo & DiGiacco, Ralph Pontiac Honda, KB Advertising Specilaities, Canadaigua Emergancy Squad
  • Year Founded:
    1971
  • Fulltime Employees:
    158
  • Active Clients:
    600,000+
  • Revenue:
    $5 million - $10 million
  • Client Retention Rate:
    90
  • Pricing:
    L
  • Website:
    www.paychex.com
Request A Quote
Negative Review 7 Reviews
Our experience with pay checks could not be w...
George Namay
Negative Review
Yep.... exactly what the last review said. It...
Christine Goodman
Negative Review
Yup. What they said. Do not give them a chanc...
Bill Amato

Methods of Payment

Tax Compliance

Automation

Volume

Support

Contenders
7
2000
$3 million - $5 million
100+
5,000+
95
L
Peak Cost Containment, American Coding & Marketing Inc Co., Roane Family Dental, Sutdio Gear Promotional Products, Moonlight Slumber, LLC
95
97
96
94
94
95.2%
NC
SurePayroll SurePayroll
Talk to a Representative: 877-956-7873
Key Facts For SurePayroll
  • Major Clients:
    Peak Cost Containment, American Coding & Marketing Inc Co., Roane Family Dental, Sutdio Gear Promotional Products, Moonlight Slumber, LLC
  • Year Founded:
    2000
  • Fulltime Employees:
    100+
  • Active Clients:
    5,000+
  • Revenue:
    $3 million - $5 million
  • Client Retention Rate:
    95
  • Pricing:
    L
  • Website:
    www.surepayroll.com
Request A Quote
Reviews (21)
Positive 47.6% 10 Reviews
Danielle G. and Natalie B. are SO helpful!!!...
Jessica Kubisch
Negative 47.6% 10 Reviews
Go elsewhere they're incompetent! We weren't...
Phuc Nguyen
Neutral 4.8% 1 Reviews
We've been using SurePayroll for about three...
Molly Novy

Methods of Payment

Tax Compliance

Automation

Volume

Support

AmCheck AmCheck
Talk to a Representative: 888-810-5305
Key Facts For AmCheck
  • Major Clients:
    Confidential
  • Year Founded:
    1996
  • Fulltime Employees:
    3
  • Active Clients:
    3,000+
  • Revenue:
    Under $250,000
  • Client Retention Rate:
    92
  • Pricing:
    L
  • Website:
    www.amcheck.com
Request A Quote
Positive 75.0% 6 Reviews
I recently joined the AmCheck team and I have...
Jessica Kallinen
Positive
I have worked for AmCheck for just under 5 mo...
Amanda Chippendale
Negative 25.0% 2 Reviews
We have had serious issues with Amcheck. We w...
Max McFadden

Methods of Payment

Tax Compliance

Automation

Volume

Support

Fastpay Payroll Services
Talk to a Representative: +1 800-996-4444
Service Offerings:
Key Facts For Fastpay Payroll Services
  • Major Clients:
    Confidential
  • Year Founded:
    2012
  • Fulltime Employees:
    10+
  • Active Clients:
    10+
  • Revenue:
    $250,000 - $1 million
  • Client Retention Rate:
    81
  • Pricing:
    M
  • Website:
    www.fastpaypayroll.com
Request A Quote
Positive0% Write Review

 

Negative0% Write Review

 

Neutral0% Write Review

 

Methods of Payment

Tax Compliance

Automation

Volume

Support

OnPay Solutions OnPay Solutions
Talk to a Representative: 904-786-6369
Key Facts For OnPay Solutions
  • Major Clients:
    Spalding Business Solutions, Inc
  • Year Founded:
    2009
  • Fulltime Employees:
    46
  • Active Clients:
    1000+
  • Revenue:
    $1 million - $3 million
  • Client Retention Rate:
    95
  • Pricing:
    L
  • Website:
    www.onpaysolutions.com
Request A Quote
Positive0% Write Review

 

Negative0% Write Review

 

Neutral0% Write Review

 

Methods of Payment

Tax Compliance

Automation

Volume

Support

Evaluation Criteria:
Methods of Payment
Methods of Payment
Tax Compliance
Tax Compliance
Automation
Automation
Volume
Volume
Support
Support
 
bestpayrollservices.com Everywhere!

Reach us from wherever you are. Get the latest updates fast.

Facebook
Facebook

Get updates and follow
us on Facebook

Twitter

Remain connected with
us on urgent updates

LinkedIn
LinkedIn

Access our company
profile page on LinkedIn

 

Copyright 2019 © bestpayrollservices.com. Use of this website constitutes acceptance of Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Legal Disclosure

Request a Quote


,

Talk to a Representative:

 
Request a Call


,

Talk to a Representative:

 
Schedule a Visit


,

Talk to a Representative: